Brazilian Judge Freezes R$ 180,000 From Meta Over a Lawmaker’s Video Criticizing Erika Hilton

HomePolitics

Brazilian Judge Freezes R$ 180,000 From Meta Over a Lawmaker’s Video Criticizing Erika Hilton

Conexão USA — Do primeiro passo ao Green Card

A São Paulo judge froze R$ 179,693.88 from Meta for leaving online, for months, a video by opposition Rep. André Fernandes that criticized leftist lawmaker Erika Hilton. The order to remove it dated from June; the video came down in October, Gazeta do Povo reported.

Aliados de Lula pedem a Moraes a prisão de Flávio Bolsonaro e o corte do salário dele
Justiça bloqueia R$ 180 mil da Meta por não apagar vídeo de deputado sobre Erika Hilton
Pope Leo Struck in the Face by an Object Hurled From the Crowd in Peru

SÃO PAULO — A Brazilian judge has frozen R$ 179,693.88 from the accounts of Meta, the American owner of Instagram and Facebook, because the company kept online a video by an opposition lawmaker criticizing another lawmaker, Gazeta do Povo reported. The ruling shows how a court order over political speech now ends in a fine for a U.S. platform.

Judge Guilherme Madeira Dezem, of the 44th Civil Court in São Paulo, authorized the freeze on Oct. 26, and the court’s asset-search system confirmed it on Nov. 11. The video was posted in May 2026 by Rep. André Fernandes (PL-CE) after a clash in the Chamber of Deputies with Rep. Erika Hilton (PSOL-SP) during a debate on ending the six-day work week.

What the video said

Hilton, who is a transgender woman, had mocked an old video of Fernandes made when he was 14. Fernandes answered with a video that used her birth name, referred to her with male pronouns and joked about her voice. On June 11 the judge ordered Meta to remove it within 24 hours, with a daily fine of R$ 5,000, first capped at R$ 50,000. Hilton’s lawyers say it stayed up until October.

Why it matters

For American readers, the key point is who pays. A Brazilian court is reaching into the accounts of a U.S. company over a post by a member of parliament, and it grounds the order in a 2019 Supreme Court ruling that placed homophobia and transphobia under Brazil’s racism law. Critics note that Congress never voted on that category: the Court itself wrote it, a pattern of lawmaking from the bench that we have followed in stories like the regime’s push to police the internet.

The same judge found in October that the post had “contours of discrimination based on gender identity,” rejected Fernandes’s claim of parliamentary immunity and ordered him to pay R$ 50,000 in damages. He added a 10% procedural fine and 10% in legal fees to the debt. He also refused to suspend the driver’s license and passport of Meta’s Brazil chief, Conrado Leister, and refused to find a crime of disobedience.

The record

What is confirmed: the freeze order of Oct. 26, the Nov. 11 confirmation, the June 11 order and the October damages ruling, all described by Gazeta do Povo. What is alleged: that Meta left the video online until October, which is the account of Hilton’s lawyers. Meta’s side was not detailed in the reporting we reviewed.

The record leaves one question that critics of the Court raise: whether a lawmaker’s speech, even crude speech, should be settled by a judge’s fine on a foreign company. Defenders of the ruling say the post targeted a person for her identity. Critics answer that a member of the opposition is being silenced through a platform, in a country where the Supreme Court already orders accounts blocked. Both things are true at once, and the pattern is clear: the penalty lands on the platform, and the speech disappears.

The Watch Post Daily will continue to follow this story. Sources: Gazeta do Povo, CNN Brasil, O Estado de S. Paulo.

Featured image: Special Committee on the end of the 6×1 work schedule, with Reps. Daiana Santos and Erika Hilton by Bruno Spada/Câmara dos Deputados, via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 3.0.

Conexão USA — Do primeiro passo ao Green Card

COMMENTS

WORDPRESS: 0