Justice Alexandre de Moraes voted to put opposition lawmaker Marcel van Hattem on trial for criticizing Fábio Shor, the federal police investigator who now advises Moraes. Van Hattem calls it political persecution, and a group of jurists says Moraes should step aside, Gazeta do Povo and Poder360 report.
BRASILIA — Supreme Court Justice Alexandre de Moraes voted on Friday, Nov. 20, to put opposition lawmaker Marcel van Hattem on trial for slander and insult against Fábio Shor, a Federal Police investigator who has worked since March as an advisor in Moraes’s own office, according to Gazeta do Povo and Poder360. Van Hattem, a Novo party deputy from Rio Grande do Sul who was elected to the Senate in October, calls the case political persecution. Justice Flávio Dino, the rapporteur, voted the same way, and Justice Cristiano Zanin then asked that the case move to an in-person session, with no date set.
The complaint covers four episodes from 2024, when Van Hattem said in speeches in the Chamber of Deputies and in online posts that Shor had produced false reports against innocent people in the investigation that put Filipe Martins, a former aide to Jair Bolsonaro, behind bars, and called him a “bandit” and a “coward.” The Attorney General’s Office (PGR) argues that he went beyond criticism of a public agent. His defense says the remarks rested on facts and are covered by Article 53 of the Constitution, which makes lawmakers inviolable for their words and opinions.
Why it matters
Article 53 does in Brazil roughly what the Speech or Debate Clause does in the United States: it lets elected lawmakers speak in the chamber without fear of being prosecuted by another branch. Here the vote to set that protection aside came from a justice whose own advisor is the offended party. Shor left the Federal Police in March when Moraes requested his transfer to the court, and before that he worked on the Jan. 8 and coup-plot investigations that Moraes oversaw, Poder360 reports. The remarks that now lead to a trial were made about a man who joined Moraes’s office a year and a half later.
Lexum, an association of jurists founded against what it calls authoritarianism at the Supreme Court, says that fact “recommends” that Moraes step aside on his own, Gazeta do Povo reports.
The persecution charge
Van Hattem says he will take the case to the presidents of the Chamber and the Senate, Poder360 reports. Lexum argues that “prosecuting those who oversee inhibits all lawmakers and weakens republican controls,” and that the vote contradicts itself, because it uses the link to the mandate to give the Supreme Court jurisdiction and then discards that link to deny immunity. Alberto Zacharias Toron, a lawyer and former president of the Brazilian Institute of Criminal Sciences, said the remarks may be “execrable,” but that inviolability “is a guarantee not of the lawmaker but of the institution he belongs to and, in the end, of liberty itself.”
The asymmetry is part of the argument. Poder360 notes that critics on social media pointed to a 2026 decision by Justice Gilmar Mendes that shelved a complaint against Lindbergh Farias, of the Workers’ Party, and Senator Soraya Thronicke, of the PSB, because Article 53 protected them. Dino, who wrote the vote against Van Hattem, served as Lula’s justice minister before Lula put him on the court. As we reported, Martins spent 1,000 days in jail over a U.S. record that a federal judge calls false, and a 61-year-old Jan. 8 defendant was ordered arrested this week.
The record
What is established: Dino and Moraes voted to accept the complaint, Zanin and Justice Cármen Lúcia have not voted, and, according to Gazeta do Povo, one more vote for the complaint makes Van Hattem a defendant. Poder360 also reports that an FGV law professor, Jean Menezes de Aguiar, says Dino’s vote follows a 1990 Supreme Court ruling that immunity must be tied to the exercise of the mandate. What is not established is whether Shor produced a false report. Van Hattem’s defense filed a U.S. border authority record saying Martins did not enter the country on the date cited in the arrest order; the PGR says that document alone does not show Shor produced a false report, and Moraes said the point will be examined during the trial.
A lawmaker who said an investigator built a case on a record that a U.S. document contradicts is now the one headed for the dock, in a vote that opens with a justice whose advisor is the man he criticized. For an opposition that already describes the court as a tool against it, the sequence reads as political persecution, and the part still to come is whether Zanin and Cármen Lúcia agree.
The Watch Post Daily will continue to follow this story. Sources: Gazeta do Povo; Poder360.
Featured image: Deputado Marcel Van Hattem (NOVO-RS) 02 by Pablo Valadares/Câmara dos Deputados, via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 3.0.



COMMENTS