Messages in a Federal Police report show banker Daniel Vorcaro and ex-minister Fábio Faria discussed a London institute for Supreme Court Justice Alexandre de Moraes, who is quoted agreeing. Estadão reported the exchange; Moraes had not responded when it ran.
BRASILIA — A Federal Police report released this week shows that banker Daniel Vorcaro, the owner of Banco Master, and former Communications Minister Fábio Faria discussed setting up a London institute for Supreme Court Justice Alexandre de Moraes, and that Moraes is quoted agreeing, according to messages analyzed by police and published by the newspaper Estadão. Estadão asked all three sides for comment.
The exchange sits in a 35-page report on references to Justice André Mendonça found on Vorcaro’s phone. Supreme Court President Edson Fachin lifted its secrecy at Mendonça’s own request. Investigators included the Moraes conversation because it mentions the Iter Institute, where Mendonça was a partner until September and from which, Estadão reports, he received more than R$ 4.8 million since it was founded in 2023.
What the messages say
On March 28, 2024, while the London legal forum was being planned, Faria forwarded Vorcaro excerpts of what he described as a WhatsApp chat with Moraes. In it, Moraes is quoted joking that someone would think he was going to set up an institute. Faria answered, “Sure. One in London would be nice,” and the justice replied, “Let’s go.” When Vorcaro asked who had written it, Faria said, “Alex sent it.” “Alex” was the nickname Vorcaro and Faria used for Moraes, per an earlier police report.
Faria then pitched the idea to the banker: “Let’s set up an institute for him in London. André Mendonça set one up. Everyone is setting them up.” An earlier message he also passed to Vorcaro referred to Justice Gilmar Mendes and the IDP, the school Mendes co-founded: “Gilmar was wary, not because of André. Because of the IDP. Competition lol.”
Why it matters
Justices who run institutes and event companies, often with relatives as partners, have become routine at the top of Brazil’s judiciary, Estadão reports. The companies, not the judges, receive the fees, which lowers the tax paid on them. The Constitution bars judges from any job except the bench and teaching, but a law from the military dictatorship lets magistrates be partners in companies. The question any democracy asks of its highest court applies: who pays for the events and institutes around the judges, and what do the payers want?
The forum itself fits that pattern. The 1st Legal Forum – Brasil de Ideias, held in London in April 2024, was sponsored by Vorcaro and brought together dozens of leaders of the three branches of government, including Moraes. Estadão previously reported that Moraes had a say over the guest list.
The record
What is established: the messages are part of a police report that Fachin made public, and Estadão has reviewed them. What is not: the lines attributed to Moraes are quoted as Faria passed them to Vorcaro, and Estadão’s account does not say whether the institute was ever created. Moraes, Faria and Vorcaro’s defense had not answered when the story ran.
The Court that will judge the cases tied to the Master scandal is the same one whose members appear in this evidence. A year in, as we reported, it was still deciding whether it could investigate itself, and Fachin has since ordered a luxury agency to hand police the trips Vorcaro paid for. A justice who answers “Let’s go” to an institute proposed to a banker now at the center of Brazil’s biggest bank scandal is not proof of a crime. It is the closeness between the powerful and their judges that institutional capture is built on, and the next test is whether prosecutors, not the Court, decide who gets investigated.
The Watch Post Daily will continue to follow this story. Sources: Estadão; Federal Police report on André Mendonça released by Supreme Court President Edson Fachin.
Featured image: Alexandre de Moraes at a ceremony in Brasília by Supremo Tribunal Federal (STF), via Wikimedia Commons, public domain, cropped.



COMMENTS