Justice André Mendonça waived secrecy on the Federal Police file that cites him in banker Daniel Vorcaro’s phone, and Chief Justice Edson Fachin released it. Fachin sent four reports to prosecutors, including those on Moraes and Toffoli, and shelved six.
BRASILIA — Brazil’s Chief Justice Edson Fachin lifted the secrecy on Friday, Nov. 20, from a Federal Police report that mentions Supreme Court Justice André Mendonça in messages found on the phone of banker Daniel Vorcaro, after Mendonça asked in writing for it to be made public. In an official letter, Mendonça said he “expressly” waived confidentiality and asked that the whole file, registered as Petition 17.146, be open to any citizen.
The release came a day after Fachin split a stack of Federal Police reports on the Master case. According to court records, the police delivered ten individual reports to Fachin on Wednesday night, Nov. 18, built from messages extracted from the phones of Vorcaro and his brother-in-law, Fabiano Zettel. Fachin sent four to the Attorney General’s Office, covering Alexandre de Moraes, Dias Toffoli, Kassio Nunes Marques and Mendonça himself. He shelved the other six, which concern Cristiano Zanin, Luiz Fux, Cármen Lúcia, Gilmar Mendes, Flávio Dino and Fachin, because they contained only passing mentions made by third parties. Prosecutors have 15 days to say whether they want an investigation.
Why it matters
Brazil’s Supreme Court has spent months deciding whether its own members can be investigated over their ties to Vorcaro, the former controller of Banco Master, as we reported this month. Fachin has said that opening a case against a justice must go to the full court. For American readers, this is a test of the oldest question in any democracy: who checks the people who check everyone else. Washington has watched the same court order the removal of accounts and the jailing of critics, and it now sits as judge of its own conduct in a banking scandal.
The contrast is in who asked for transparency. Mendonça is the justice who made public, in early September, a police report with 52 messages Vorcaro allegedly sent to a number tied to Moraes, along with records of meetings and contracts between the bank and the law firm of Moraes’s wife, Viviane Barci. Vorcaro also moved up a flight to Dubai after talking to Moraes and then meeting him, according to earlier reporting. Moraes denied any contact and, according to press accounts, sent Fachin police intelligence reports claiming “strong indications” of abuse of authority by Mendonça, which Mendonça rejects. Reporting so far does not show the other three justices whose files went to prosecutors asking for theirs to be opened.
What the Mendonça file says
The report was assembled from third-party conversations. The Federal Police say they found no direct messages between Mendonça and Vorcaro. The file does record a March 14, 2025 meeting at the Iter Institute in São Paulo, arranged by lawyer Ciro Soares and Congressman Cezinha de Madureira. Mendonça’s office confirmed in September that he received Vorcaro once, at the banker’s initiative, that he only listened, and that the subject was a dispute over court-ordered payment credits in which he later ruled against Vorcaro’s position. The report also includes a February 2025 message in which Soares sends a photo with the justice and says he took him to a tailor in São Paulo, plus invitations to events tied to the justice and messages in which Vorcaro follows Supreme Court trials where Mendonça voted against interests mentioned in the chats.
The record
The Federal Police describe the file as preliminary and descriptive. It makes no judgment about crimes, and it is not an investigation of Mendonça, which would need the full court’s approval. The reports on Moraes, Toffoli and Nunes Marques have not been made public so far as reporting shows, and their contents remain allegations, not findings. Moraes’s accusations against Mendonça and Mendonça’s denial are both unresolved.
What can be said is simple. One justice named in the Master case asked for his file to be published, and the Federal Police’s own summary does not show a direct line to the banker. The three colleagues whose reports are now with prosecutors, and the court that will decide what happens next, have not offered the same openness. How the Attorney General’s Office handles those four files in the next two weeks will say a great deal about whether Brazil’s highest court can be audited by anyone outside it.
The Watch Post Daily will continue to follow this story. Sources: Supreme Court and Federal Police records as reported by Brazilian outlets.
Featured image: Justice André Mendonça in October 2025 by Rosinei Coutinho/STF, via Wikimedia Commons, public domain, cropped.



COMMENTS