The Lula regime formally asked the World Trade Organization to rule on Trump’s tariffs after talks failed in Geneva. G1 reports Brazilian officials see no sign the tariffs will be reversed, and the move is mostly symbolic.
BRASILIA — The Lula regime asked the World Trade Organization this week to rule on the tariffs President Donald Trump imposed on Brazilian goods, formally admitting that its consultations with Washington produced no deal, according to G1 and Poder360. The request entered the WTO system on Wednesday, Nov. 18, though it is dated Nov. 13, and Brazil wants the Dispute Settlement Body to decide on setting up a panel at its meeting on Nov. 24.
Brazil opened the case in July and challenges two tariffs: a 25% duty, which the White House justified with alleged unfair practices on the PIX payment system, deforestation and intellectual property, and a 12.5% duty tied to the U.S. finding that dozens of countries, Brazil among them, failed to block imports made with forced labor. Representatives of both countries met in Geneva on Sept. 25. “Unfortunately, these consultations failed to resolve the dispute,” the Brazilian filing says, as quoted by G1. Washington had accepted the consultations on Aug. 10 and said it was available to talk. The same day, China asked to join the case, and the United States objected.
Why it matters
The route runs through a body whose appeals mechanism has been paralyzed since 2019, when Trump, in his first term, blocked the appointment of new judges, G1 notes. Brazilian officials told the network there is no sign the tariffs will be reversed, and G1 describes the move as more symbolic and institutional than practical, with the chances of a settlement through the WTO “almost nil.” For American exporters and for investors in the two largest economies of the hemisphere, the dispute is now locked in a forum that cannot force anyone to pay or to back down.
Brazilian negotiators say the motive behind the tariffs was political, not commercial. They point out that the United States runs a trade surplus with Brazil, not a deficit, that illegal deforestation has fallen in recent years, and that the International Labour Organization treats Brazil as a reference in fighting forced labor. Aides to Lula also told G1 that Trump seemed unaware of the details during a recent phone call with the president. Those are the regime’s arguments, not findings by the WTO or by Washington.
The timing sits oddly with the rest of the week. Earlier this week, the Lula regime’s leader in Congress proposed a 3% tax on the digital revenue of big tech, most of it American, and Lula has been attacking Trump’s Shield of the Americas in public. A government that asks Geneva for relief while taxing American companies at home, and with China asking to join its case, is not negotiating a way out. It is building a record, and the tariffs stay where they are.
The record
The dates, the quoted passage of the filing and the details of the two tariffs come from the G1 report by TV Globo’s Filipe Matoso, and the request was also reported by Poder360. The assessment that the move is symbolic is G1’s, and the claim that the tariffs are political is the Brazilian negotiators’ own view. The G1 report includes no response from the U.S. government to the new request. Whether a panel is set up on Nov. 24 is still open.
The Watch Post Daily will continue to follow this story. Sources: G1 (TV Globo) and Poder360.
Featured image: Unloading a container ship in the port of Vitória by Alacoolwiki, via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0.



COMMENTS