Federal Police Charge 17 in Brazil’s Ventilator Scandal and Spare Lula Ally Rui Costa

HomeSecurity

Federal Police Charge 17 in Brazil’s Ventilator Scandal and Spare Lula Ally Rui Costa

Conexão USA — Do primeiro passo ao Green Card

Brazil’s Federal Police charged 17 people over 300 pandemic ventilators that were paid for and never delivered, but left out Rui Costa, Lula’s former chief of staff, and his wife. The police itself says the evidence that could have reached them was lost.

Lula negocia com Alcolumbre a vaga no STF depois da derrota de Messias; Tebet é cotada
Lula Negotiates the Next Supreme Court Seat With Senate Chief Alcolumbre After the Messias Defeat
Justiça bloqueia R$ 180 mil da Meta por não apagar vídeo de deputado sobre Erika Hilton

BRASILIA — Brazil’s Federal Police closed its six-year investigation into 300 pandemic ventilators that were paid for in advance and never delivered, charging 17 people and leaving out the man who ran the purchase: Rui Costa, the former Bahia governor who later became President Lula’s chief of staff and was just elected to the Senate. His wife, Aline Peixoto, who was also under investigation, was left out too, according to the final report sent on Sunday, Nov. 15, to Justice Og Fernandes of the Superior Court of Justice (STJ), as reported by Folha de S.Paulo and Gazeta do Povo.

The deal dates to 2020. The Consórcio Nordeste, a purchasing alliance of northeastern states then chaired by Costa, paid R$ 48.7 million up front to a company that, according to Brazil’s federal comptroller (CGU), sold cannabis-based medicines and had no proven experience or financial capacity to deliver hospital equipment. The ventilators never arrived. Bahia’s state audit court later pointed to “gross administrative errors” and recommended rejecting Costa’s accounts for that year.

Those charged include business owners, middlemen, Bahia’s former state chief of staff Bruno Dauster and the consortium’s former executive secretary Carlos Gabas, for crimes ranging from bid fraud and money laundering to corruption and criminal organization. The governor who chaired the consortium when the money went out is not on the list.

Why it matters

Costa is not a peripheral figure. He was the most powerful minister in the Lula regime, the official who ran the presidential palace’s day-to-day machinery, and he now takes a Senate seat with the privileges that come with it. For American readers, the case is a clean test of whether Brazil’s law enforcement applies the same standard to the ruling party’s inner circle that it applies to the opposition. The answer this week was no.

The contrast is hard to miss. The same Federal Police moved within minutes against opposition figures after the election, and its chief recently ordered an investigation into one of his own officers for criticizing him on social media. Lula’s allies, meanwhile, are asking the Supreme Court to jail opposition leader Flávio Bolsonaro.

The record

What the police report itself says is the strongest part of the story. Investigators wrote that Costa and his wife were mentioned “at various moments,” including in plea-bargain testimony, but that no “first-person record” tied them to the facts. They then explained why: the evidence that could have led to such records had been lost because of the way the investigation started, which, in the report’s words, “was apparently dictated deliberately by the investigated themselves,” when they chose to file a complaint with Bahia’s state police with “selective information.” The report adds that Aline Peixoto was never questioned, that Costa was heard only at an “incipient” stage, and that a two-year delay before searches “certainly neutralized” the means to clarify their role.

Costa’s office says the report shows the references to him came from third parties and that he never took part in any irregularity. That is his position, and it is on the record. What is also on the record is that the police did not clear him on the merits. It said it could not reach him because the evidence was gone.

A scandal in which the money vanished, the equipment never came and the investigation was steered from the start by the people under suspicion ends with the regime’s most powerful minister untouched and a Senate seat waiting for him. This happens under a government whose 2022 victory remains disputed by millions of Brazilians, and it shows how the system works for those inside it: the friends of the Lula regime are protected, and everyone else is a target.

The Watch Post Daily will continue to follow this story. Sources: Folha de S.Paulo, Gazeta do Povo, Correio, Federal Police final report as reported by Folha, Brazil’s federal comptroller (CGU).

Featured image: 26.08.2025 – Reunião Ministerial – 54746467576.jpg by Lula Oficial, via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0.

Conexão USA — Do primeiro passo ao Green Card

COMMENTS

WORDPRESS: 0