President Lula plans to meet Senate chief Davi Alcolumbre this week to agree on his next Supreme Court nominee and the confirmation calendar, after the Senate rejected Jorge Messias, Gazeta do Povo reported. Simone Tebet is among the names, and 19 groups are asking for a woman.
BRASILIA — President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva plans to meet Senate President Davi Alcolumbre this week to settle his next Supreme Court nominee, and the confirmation calendar, before announcing anything, Gazeta do Povo reported. The goal is to avoid a second defeat after the Senate rejected his earlier pick, Jorge Messias, for the seat left open when Justice Luís Roberto Barroso retired.
Government officials told the newspaper that the meeting should happen after Lula returns to Brazil from trips to Spain and to the ASEAN summit in Asia. This time, unlike with Messias, the regime wants Alcolumbre’s blessing on the name and on the process first. Alcolumbre had shown irritation at not being consulted before the Messias announcement and ran that process in open disagreement with the presidential palace.
The names
The plan is to announce the nominee in November, so that the Senate Constitution and Justice Committee can hold its hearing in early December. Gazeta do Povo lists three names in the talks: Rodrigo Pacheco, a federal audit court justice and former Senate president; Paulo Gonet, the prosecutor general; and Simone Tebet, a former planning minister. Estadão reports that allies regret the chance of losing Tebet from the government. Veja reports that 19 groups have asked Lula to pick a woman, and that justices expect the announcement this week.
Why it matters
An American reader may remember that a president’s Supreme Court pick is a political fight, but in Brazil the fight has a twist. Lula says he wants to hear several sitting justices before choosing, including Alexandre de Moraes, Flávio Dino, Cristiano Zanin and Gilmar Mendes, as we reported. The people who will judge the cases of his government and its allies help pick their next colleague. And the chief justice has campaigned in public on the choice, as we reported earlier.
The calendar is also a message. The Planalto wants a name confirmed this year to avoid what it expects from 2027, when the right holds a larger share of Congress. In other words, the regime is racing the new Senate, because a vote under the new balance of power might turn out differently. This happens after an election whose result millions of Brazilians doubt, and the Senate’s rejection of Messias was one of the few times an institution said no to the ruling party.
The record
What is confirmed: Gazeta do Povo’s account of the planned meeting, the intended timeline and the three names, based on government sources, and the rejection of Messias. What is not confirmed: any decision. Lula has not announced a nominee, and Alcolumbre has not commented on the plan in the reports we reviewed. The 19 groups and the expected announcement date come from Veja and are not official.
The lesson is in the order of events. A nominee is being agreed upon first with the man who controls the Senate floor and then, if the plan works, sent for a hearing in a few weeks. That is politics, and every democracy does it. What deserves attention is the result: a Court that decides on elections, on speech and on the opposition’s freedom is about to gain a new member chosen by the same ruling party it often favors, with a calendar built to beat the next Congress.
The Watch Post Daily will continue to follow this story. Sources: Gazeta do Povo, O Estado de S. Paulo, Veja.
Featured image: Simone Tebet concede entrevista by Agência Senado, via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0.



COMMENTS