Justice Alexandre de Moraes is still the rapporteur in 222 of the 229 pending criminal cases at Brazil’s Supreme Court, or 96.9%, even after the fake news inquiry he ran for seven years was archived, Gazeta do Povo reports.
BRASILIA — Justice Alexandre de Moraes is still the judge of almost every pending criminal case at Brazil’s Supreme Court, even after the court closed the fake news inquiry he ran for more than seven years, according to a tally based on the court’s Corte Aberta data and reported by Gazeta do Povo. He is the rapporteur in 222 of the 229 criminal cases still awaiting a final decision, or 96.9%, and in 212 of the 215 sentence-enforcement cases, or 98.6%.
The fake news inquiry was opened in March 2019, when then-Chief Justice Dias Toffoli named Moraes its rapporteur to look into false news, threats and attacks against justices and the court. Over time it absorbed other fronts and fed the investigations into anti-democratic acts and the Jan. 8, 2023 riots. Chief Justice Edson Fachin archived it after the prosecutor general’s office said there was no reason to keep it open indefinitely, and ordered its offshoots to be examined one by one. According to Gazeta do Povo, the numbers show the closing “did not significantly change” how much of the criminal docket sits with Moraes.
Why it matters
The cases that stayed on his desk include the sentence of former President Jair Bolsonaro, convicted to 27 years and three months in prison over the alleged coup plot, where Moraes rules on prison conditions, requests for benefits and changes in the sentence regime. The same justice presided over the electoral court during the 2022 election that millions of Brazilians still dispute. For American readers who track the rule of law in the hemisphere, the question is simple: when one judge controls the investigations, the trials and the prisons, who checks him? Our earlier reporting on how Moraes decides who guards Bolsonaro, and who gets to visit him shows how far that reach goes.
The numbers
Moraes reports 15 of the 55 inquiries now open at the Supreme Court, or 27.2%. Of the 222 criminal cases under him, 97 were opened in 2026, which is 43.7%, while 45 date from 2023, 42 from 2024 and 38 from 2025. The next justice on the list, Cármen Lúcia, has three criminal cases awaiting a final decision, and Nunes Marques has two. In other words, one justice carries more than thirty times as many pending criminal cases as the other ten combined, the kind of asymmetry we flagged when Moraes took the Supreme Court chair while the court sat on his own case.
The record
The figures come from Gazeta do Povo’s analysis of Corte Aberta, the Supreme Court’s public data portal, and count only cases without a final decision. The article gives two slightly different tallies for inquiries, 15 of 55 and 17 of 57, without explaining the gap; this report uses the first. Fachin’s archiving order and the prosecutor general’s opinion are reported in the same piece. No source cited by Gazeta do Povo alleges that cases were assigned irregularly; the concentration is documented, and what it means is a matter of editorial judgment.
Closing the inquiry removed a label, not a caseload. One justice still shapes who is investigated, who is tried and where sentences are served, and the next thing to watch is whether Fachin’s case-by-case review of the offshoots sends any of them to another desk.
The Watch Post Daily will continue to follow this story. Sources: Gazeta do Povo, citing Corte Aberta (Brazilian Supreme Court); O Globo.
Featured image: Unveiling of the portrait of former TSE president Alexandre de Moraes by O Tribunal da Democracia, via Wikimedia Commons, public domain.



COMMENTS