Bolsonaro’s Last Legal Hope Goes Before the Same Court That Convicted Him

HomeSecurity

Bolsonaro’s Last Legal Hope Goes Before the Same Court That Convicted Him

Conexão USA — Do primeiro passo ao Green Card

Justice Kassio Nunes Marques is expected to take Jair Bolsonaro's criminal review to the full Supreme Court after the prosecutor general opposed it. The four justices who convicted the former president will vote again on his last legal chance.

Iran and Hamas Rushed to Hail Lula’s Win, Flávio Says, and His Party Conceded Out of Fear
Copa Jet Clips a UPS Cargo Plane at Miami Airport as U.S. Air Travel Chaos Drags On
Além de Lula, 34 alvos da Lava Jato “venceram” as eleições de 2026

BRASILIA — Justice Kassio Nunes Marques is expected to take Jair Bolsonaro’s request for a criminal review of his conviction to the full Supreme Court, after Prosecutor General Paulo Gonet asked the court on Thursday, Nov. 12, not to even admit it, CNN Brasil reported on Sunday, Nov. 15. The former president is serving 27 years and three months in prison for an alleged coup attempt. Since his son, Senator Flávio Bolsonaro, lost the October runoff to Lula, the review has become the defense’s main hope, and the last legal chance of the opposition’s best-known political prisoner will be decided by the same court that convicted him.

Kassio, the case’s rapporteur, plans to send it to the full bench rather than to the Second Panel, where he sits. The trial date is up to the court’s chief justice, Edson Fachin. Before that, Kassio may rule alone on the defense’s request to suspend the sentence, a decision the other justices would later have to confirm. This is Bolsonaro’s second criminal review request under Kassio; the first, filed in May, also drew a negative opinion from the prosecutor general and is still waiting for a decision.

What the defense argues

Bolsonaro’s lawyers point to irregularities in how digital evidence was collected and preserved, an improper role for Justice Alexandre de Moraes in the investigations, and a defense that was denied a fair chance: they were given limited time to review some 70 terabytes of material supplied by the Federal Police. Gonet answered that the technical reports filed by the defense are not new evidence, since they examine material already available during the trial, and that no tampering able to compromise the evidence was shown. Even without the disputed digital files, he wrote, recordings, handwritten notes, official records and testimony would support the conviction.

Why it matters

Bolsonaro was convicted in 2025 by the court’s First Panel, with votes from Moraes, Cristiano Zanin, Cármen Lúcia and Flávio Dino; Luiz Fux voted to acquit. Those four justices will vote again in the full court. Kassio, André Mendonça, Gilmar Mendes, Fachin and Dias Toffoli, who did not take part in the original trial, will be heard for the first time. With one seat still empty, the defense would need almost every one of the justices who stayed out of the first trial. A wing of the court close to Moraes sees little room for the request to succeed and rejects both annulling the conviction and suspending the sentence this way, according to CNN Brasil. For Americans, imagine a former president’s only appeal being heard by the same judges who convicted him, one of whom also led the investigation. We have already shown how Moraes decides who guards Bolsonaro and who may visit him.

The record

Confirmed: the prosecutor general’s opinion, sent on Nov. 12, and Kassio’s plan to take the case to the full court, as reported by CNN Brasil. Bolsonaro’s conviction is a court ruling; the claims of tainted evidence and of Moraes’s improper role are the defense’s arguments and have not been accepted by the court. No date has been set.

A criminal review exists to correct a judicial error. Here, the error the defense alleges involves the justice who investigated, the panel that convicted and the court that will now review itself. The outcome will show whether Brazil’s Supreme Court can still say “we were wrong” about the country’s main opposition leader, or whether, under a regime whose 2022 victory millions of Brazilians still dispute, the court has become both prosecutor and final judge. A recent poll shows how many Brazilians already doubt the system’s fairness.

The Watch Post Daily will continue to follow this story. Sources: CNN Brasil (Fernanda Fonseca), Office of the Prosecutor General (PGR).

Featured image: Justice Kassio Nunes Marques at a plenary session, February 2025 by the Superior Electoral Court (TSE), via Wikimedia Commons, public domain.

Conexão USA — Do primeiro passo ao Green Card

COMMENTS

WORDPRESS: 0