Lula Attacks Big Tech in Asia Days Before Brazil’s House Votes to Rein It In

HomePolitics

Lula Attacks Big Tech in Asia Days Before Brazil’s House Votes to Rein It In

Conexão USA — Do primeiro passo ao Green Card

At the ASEAN summit in the Philippines, Lula said big tech's power threatens national sovereignty. On Tuesday, Brazil's House is set to vote on his regime's bill giving antitrust agency CADE new powers over mostly American platforms, a bill already flagged by the U.S. Trade Representative.

To Brazil’s Victor Goes Political Revenge
Regulators Never Saw Moraes’s Wife, Hired for R$129 Million by Brazilian Lender Banco Master
Alcolumbre Weighs Sending Lula’s Supreme Court Pick Back Without a Hearing

MANILA — Speaking at the 49th summit of the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) in the Philippines on Saturday, Nov. 14, President Lula told the region’s leaders that “the excessive concentration of technological power represents a growing threat to our societies” and that “the designs of the big technology companies cannot override the sovereignty of states and the rights of citizens,” according to the transcript of the speech published by CNN Brasil and reporting by O Antagonista. Three days later, on Tuesday, Nov. 17, Brazil’s House of Representatives is scheduled to vote on the Lula regime’s bill that hands the country’s antitrust agency new powers over those same companies.

Lula spoke third, after Philippine President Ferdinand Marcos Jr. and Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney. He praised Indonesia, Malaysia and the Philippines for their rules on minors online and cited Brazil’s new Digital Statute of Children and Adolescents, approved this year. In the same speech he said that “citizens of the Global South pay the price for unfair tariffs and irresponsible vetoes,” a line that fits the regime’s running fight with Washington over the tariffs on Brazilian goods, which Brasília has already taken to the WTO.

What the bill does

The bill, PL 4.675/2025, reported in the House by Rep. Aliel Machado (PV-PR), creates a digital markets office inside CADE, Brazil’s antitrust agency. Companies labeled of “systemic relevance” could face special obligations, and CADE could act before a merger or a business practice causes harm, instead of after a complaint, as it does today. The revenue thresholds in the latest draft are R$50 billion worldwide or R$5 billion in Brazil, but reaching them is not enough: CADE would also weigh six qualitative criteria, case by case. We covered the regime’s push to fast-track the bill earlier this week.

Why it matters

The companies the bill is built to reach are, for the most part, American. The White House has noticed. In April, the office of the U.S. Trade Representative listed PL 4.675 in the Brazil chapter of its annual report on foreign trade barriers, next to ethanol tariffs and the Pix payment system. In July, 20 Republican members of Congress wrote to the USTR asking for a firm defense of U.S. tech companies, citing the Brazilian bill by name. According to CNN Brasil’s Brasília bureau chief, Daniel Rittner, the subject has come up in tariff talks between the Trump and Lula administrations more than once.

Criticism inside Brazil is also on the record. A study by the Latin American Internet Association (ALAI), prepared by Ecoa Consultoria, warns that the bill does not say clearly which companies will be covered, leaves key terms such as “digital ecosystems,” “dependence” and “significant quantity of data” open to interpretation, and needs safeguards so that forced data-sharing does not put user privacy at risk. ALAI asked that the bill not be voted under urgency without public hearings. On Friday, a group of economists, professors and civil society organizations released statements in favor of passage.

The record

The quotes above come from the official text of the speech. The Tuesday vote was scheduled after a meeting at the presidential palace with House Speaker Hugo Motta, CNN Brasil reported. What is not settled is the reach of the law: the regime and the rapporteur say it deals only with markets and competition, not content, while the tech companies argue it opens the door to government interference in their algorithms.

The timing is the argument. A president who travels to Asia to speak about “sovereignty” against technology companies, while his allies rush a bill at home that lets a government agency decide, one case at a time, which foreign platforms must obey special rules, is not making a speech about children’s safety. He is building support abroad for a fight with Washington, under a regime whose 2022 victory remains disputed by millions of Brazilians who allege electronic ballot fraud. Congress should hear from the people this law will reach before it votes, not after.

The Watch Post Daily will continue to follow this story. Sources: CNN Brasil (João Ker; Duda Cambraia; Daniel Rittner), O Antagonista, official transcript of President Lula’s speech at the 49th ASEAN Summit.

Featured image: Lula at the 2025 ASEAN Business and Investment Summit in Kuala Lumpur by Lula Oficial, via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0.

Conexão USA — Do primeiro passo ao Green Card

COMMENTS

WORDPRESS: 0