Lula Asks Four Supreme Court Justices to Help Pick Their Next Colleague

HomePolitics

Lula Asks Four Supreme Court Justices to Help Pick Their Next Colleague

Conexão USA — Do primeiro passo ao Green Card

Lula will meet justices Gilmar Mendes, Cristiano Zanin, Flávio Dino and Alexandre de Moraes this week about the open seat on Brazil's Supreme Court, O Globo reported. The four will push former Senate President Rodrigo Pacheco, a name Lula has so far resisted.

Caos aéreo nos EUA: jato da Copa bate em cargueiro da UPS no aeroporto de Miami
Iran and Hamas Rushed to Hail Lula’s Win, Flávio Says, and His Party Conceded Out of Fear
Lula and 34 Car Wash Targets “Won” Brazil’s 2026 Election

BRASILIA — President Lula has a meeting scheduled this week with four sitting Supreme Court justices, Gilmar Mendes, Cristiano Zanin, Flávio Dino and Alexandre de Moraes, to discuss who should fill the court’s open seat, columnist Lauro Jardim reported in O Globo on Sunday, Nov. 15. According to the column, the four will press Lula to name former Senate President Rodrigo Pacheco, a name the president has so far shown signs of rejecting.

The seat has been empty since Justice Luís Roberto Barroso retired early in October 2025. Lula’s first choice, his attorney general Jorge Messias, was voted down by the Senate in April, 42 to 34, the first rejection of a Supreme Court nominee in 132 years. Since then, Senate President Davi Alcolumbre has weighed sending Messias back without a hearing if his name returns, and Chief Justice Edson Fachin has campaigned in public for a Black woman on the bench.

Who is in the room

Two of the four justices were named by Lula himself in his third term: Zanin was his personal lawyer in the Lava Jato cases, and Dino was his justice minister. Gilmar Mendes, the court’s longest-serving member, must retire in 2030, a seat Lula will also fill. Moraes is the justice who led the cases against Jair Bolsonaro and his allies. Their candidate, Pacheco, presided over the Senate from 2021 to 2025 and confirmed both Zanin and Dino without trouble. He now sits on the Federal Audit Court (TCU), a seat he took during the campaign, and is backed by Alcolumbre and House Speaker Hugo Motta. Part of Lula’s Workers’ Party (PT) accuses him of doing too little for Lula in the election, Estadão reported; Pacheco did not comment.

Why it matters

Lula will choose four justices by 2030: Barroso’s seat now, then Luiz Fux’s in 2028, Cármen Lúcia’s in 2029 and Gilmar’s in 2030, according to Gazeta do Povo. If all four are confirmed, presidents from the PT will have named eight of the court’s eleven members. Brazil’s Supreme Court is not a distant appeals court: it decides who is jailed, who is silenced online and who may run for office. Imagine an American president inviting four sitting justices to the White House to help pick their next colleague, and the justices arriving with a name of their own. In Brasília, that meeting is on the calendar.

The obstacle is the Senate. Confirmation needs 41 votes in a secret ballot, and from February 2027 the Liberal Party (PL), Bolsonaro’s party, will hold the largest bloc, with 29 seats against 10 for the PT, Gazeta do Povo reported. Analysts quoted by the paper expect nominees close to the president to face organized resistance.

The record

The meeting and the justices’ preference for Pacheco were reported by Lauro Jardim’s column; neither the presidential palace nor the court has commented publicly. Lula has not named a new nominee, and the column does not say whether he has accepted Pacheco.

The Constitution gives the president the choice and the Senate the vote. It gives the sitting justices no role at all. When the same men who will judge the regime’s cases, and its opponents, sit down with the president to shape the court’s next majority, the separation of powers becomes a formality. It happens under a regime whose 2022 victory remains disputed by millions of Brazilians who allege electronic ballot fraud, and whose justices have treated those doubts as a crime. The new conservative Senate is now the only check left in the process.

The Watch Post Daily will continue to follow this story. Sources: O Globo (Lauro Jardim), Gazeta do Povo (Aline Rechmann), Estadão (Coluna do Estadão).

Featured image: Alexandre de Moraes at a ceremony with President Lula, July 2026 by Supremo Tribunal Federal (STF), via Wikimedia Commons, public domain.

Conexão USA — Do primeiro passo ao Green Card

COMMENTS

WORDPRESS: 0